Scams

Inside Track – Investors suffer as Buy-to-Let backfires

If it looks too good to be true… walk away…
The golden rule with property investment and development is research, research and more research and of course the oft used phrase of location, location and location.

If a new build developer or selling agent offers you a discount from so called "normal price" simply ask yourself why the skilled new build developer or agent needs to do this to sell the property.

Editor

*****************

All 49 flats in this block in Manchester are owned by amateur investors – 37 of them thanks to one property club. Now it is feared that their value has slumped by HALF – or worse – in four years.

Richard Dyson, Financial Mail -16 March 2008

Liability: Bridgewater view in Monton, Manchester

The get-rich-quick advertising of property investment club Inside Track has persuaded more than 100,000 people to attend seminars in the past few years.

But profits at the privately owned club, which are generated mainly by recommending newly built properties to fee-paying members, are sliding.

And the number of people prepared to sign up for its £2,500-a-time seminars has plunged.

The firm, Britain’s biggest property club, last week axed 44 staff and announced it would cease offering free taster seminars held at hotels and conference centres. But it is not just Inside Track that is suffering – so are some of its clients.

Falling property values, a shortage of tenants and an oversupply of certain types of homes mean some landlords are losing money fast. Lenders are even turning away some landlords (see below), or forcing them to pay punishing rates of interest.

Inside Track boss Tony McKay admits the market is difficult. ‘There is less demand for seminars,’ he says. ‘We are focusing on existing members who are still buying properties but at a slower rate.’ There are 10,000 members, most of whom have bought membership for a fee of several thousand pounds paid on top of the £2,500 seminar bill and McKay says most are happy. Not all, however.

Photographer Gary Hynes, 51, and dozens of others are sitting on mounting losses through investing in a block of flats called Bridgewater View in Monton, Manchester.

Before the block was built in 2004, Inside Track urged investors to buy two-bedroom flats it said were worth £140,000 and likely to attract up to £650 a month in rent. It is not known what the properties are worth today, but a two-bedroom flat in the development failed to sell at auction in December for a guide price of £70,000. The flat is now let for £425 a month.

Gary, from Oxton, The Wirral, and other Inside Track members are failing to cover their mortgages with rental income. They are having to dip into their savings to meet their mortgage bills and at least one is thought to have had his property repossessed.

The development of 49 flats, all bought by amateur landlords, and in 37 cases on the recommendation of Inside Track, has been beset by problems. The location, build quality and security have been cited as just a few of many troubles. Inside Track denies responsibility.

Property analysis

This is Money’s expert analysis

Detective

• Is buy-to-let on the brink of collapse?
• Will there be a house price crash?
• How to buy a bargain home in a slump
• Would you be better off buying or renting a home?
• Video: Behind the scenes at property auctions

Last autumn the block’s managing agent, a surveyor firm from Knutsford in Cheshire, quit, saying: ‘Of 120 developments we manage, we have never experienced ongoing problems of this nature or magnitude.’

On top of membership fees to join Inside Track, and the seminars they paid for, investors in this block also paid a ‘finder’s fee’ to the property club in return for the recommendation. Gary estimates he has paid Inside Track more than £9,000 in fees, including a finder’s fee of £4,540.

Gary Hynes

Big losses: Gary Hynes could be £50,000 worse off because of his property investment.

His total losses, including the estimated fall in the value of the flat, exceed £50,000, he says, and losses are mounting at £200 a month. ‘What we were offered was an armchair service where we were to trust the advice given to us by Inside Track,’ he says.

‘It promised to do due diligence, check out these properties and recommend the best.’

More than 20 investors in the block have complained to the company. It has since paid for a security firm to make random visits to the site but denied any failure on its part.

McKay says that Inside Track relied on other experts for the recommendation and adds that just one out of ten developments meets its requirements as being suitable for investors. ‘We’re communicating with investors and we’ve helped where we can,’ he says. ‘When things go wrong, we do our utmost to put matters right.’

Inside Track will soon publish its accounts for 2007 and these are expected to show a sharp fall in profits and numbers of people at free seminars. In 2006, the number of attendees fell to 25,000 from 32,000 the year before. The number paying the £2,500 fee dropped to 3,400 from 4,400.

Squeezed lenders cut risky loans

Inside Track’s promises are tempting: ‘How to retire completely debt-free in three to five years’ and ‘how to buy lucrative UK property with little or no deposit’.

Whether such goals are realistic is questionable, but life has got harder for all property investors, especially those in newly built, inner-city flats. That is because of the change in mortgage lenders’ attitudes to risk.

Lee Grandin of specialist broker Landlord Mortgages says: ‘New-build is an area where experienced landlords do not invest. In a rising market, novices can make money buying anything, but that doesn’t work in a stagnant market.

‘Lenders have been stung and are taking action to protect themselves by refusing to lend or demanding bigger deposits. People who have bought in the past couple of years have been hit hard and, yes, they could struggle to remortgage.’

Nationwide Building Society will not lend money to landlords of new properties, while Coventry wants a 50% deposit on such properties. Other lenders to tighten terms on new flats include Kensington, GMAC, Woolwich and Abbey.

Lenders also worry about mortgage fraud. This has mostly involved newly built properties that have been overvalued.

WANT TO KNOW MORE?